Counterfeit 1848 Half Dollar

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Coloration looks weird, date looks weird, pimple on Liberty's cheek, what else?
(not a series I know much about)

 

Now that scares the pants off me..... I would have been a buyer too. I felt pretty good about my counterfeit detection ability on series that I collect.... Until today.

 

Good catch. My first thought is Liberty's left arm looks puffy.

 

Although I’m not familiar with the series, the toning looks strange
I kinda stick to graded for anything over $200
Scary

 

At First glance obviously an nice example, but looking closer

 

Here is an MS-65 graded piece from PCGS Coinfacts. Yes, this fake is scary.

 

What does the OP coin weigh?

 

After looking at the OP coin and the certified one there are so many things wrong with the fake; denticles, hair, fingers, neckline, ... That's before comparing reverses.

 

Well…. Lady Liberty certainly had a Botox lip treatment on the fake… But at first blush, I would have carried that one home.

 

There are a bunch of varieties for the date...

 

For those of us less familiar with this series, can you point out a couple of the most obvious places to look to identify this fake?

 

The lettering on thexreverse the biggest tell. Too fat too mushy and conjoined. He’d face is off too. Those the first tells

 

The filled in 4 of the date. The lack of fine definition on the drapery folds also east tells. At a quick glance to an untrained eye it looks good. On some close study it looks really bad

 

Well, that's just the thing that's throwing me. Normally, mushy lettering is one of my first tells. But, this lettering seems crisper than your typical fake. Comparing it to the genuine piece John Milton posted, the lettering doesn't really seem that off - nothing I can't account for with die wear, or a different die pairing.

 

Yeah. It’s I feel a better fake. But the overall feel from someone who’s handled and studied a lot of seated coinage is it doesn’t look right. It’s subtle but off. The date in particular

 

I don't think it is scary, it is obviously fake but not scary. Way too much eye liner and hairspray.

 

As someone who hasn't handled much seated coinage, I appreciate y'all's expertise. That's why I'm asking questions!

 

The hair looked really cheesy to me. Overall the whole coin has a cartoon-y look. But the title told me it was fake, so...