You Think She'd Come Back a 64DMPL?

... ANACS 1st Gen. slab MS63DMPL 1882-CC Morgan w/ intense rainbow toning (pink, blue, and purple hues). I thought that possibly due to the attractive toning that it would have a chance at coming back in an MS64DMPL holder if I were to crack-it-out and send it in for grading to PCGS. Do you think that it is a possiblity? What would you personally pay for this particular coin? Please leave all thoughts, opinions, and comments below!

Thanks in Advance,
Brian

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

It looks like she has a gash or other defect on her face. I think that might keep her from grading higher.

 

I thought the exact same thing, but I don't believe it's as deep as the photo makes it out to be. Also, I'm fairly sure that it is still a bag mark. Not something done after it had been put into circulation (or technically a collection). But, my main question in the matter is the toning. Is it enough to compensate for additional bag marks that a 63 may have? And even if it were still a true 63, would you pay anymore of a premium for the toning included?

-Brian

 

I'm with the others in that I wouldn't crack it out and send it in for regrading due to the gash on Liberty's cheek.

 

Even if it stays a 63 DMPL, you will then have it in a PCGS holder, which may command a much higher premium than an ANACS slab.

 

It's cool the way it is. I'm not sure PCGS would go 63. I would not risk it.

 

In this case I don't think a PCGS slab would bring more than the one it's in. Everyone knows the grading was better when this piece was slabbed. They might assign it a better grade, but standards are loose, if not ridiculous these days.
Guy

 

go for it ... it may not get an upgrade but a 63 will still increase its value as opposed to a ANACS holder

 

i would say leave it as it is. there are to many variables to risk trying to regrade that coin

 

If you send it to PCGS for a cross over you can tell them what minimum grade you will accept. If it does not hit that number they will leave it in the ANACS slab.

 

i think it will stay ms63. i just bought a different year ms64 http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=1157&lotNo=4181

 

I was thinking the same thing.

And to the original poster, I wouldn't crack it out for fear of it coming back in a PCGS "Genuine" holder.

 

Last couple of ANACS MS63 DMPL sold in the low $300's at auctions. Some NGC and PCGS sold for around same amount

 

Beautiful coin brian. If i were you i wouldnt crack it out. If it came back 64 that would be great but pcgs sometimes seems to be a tougher grader than even ngc so id be worried that it would come back 62

 

I doubt it would go for a MS64.There are many contact marks on the cheek. It is still a nice coin.

 

I don't think it would come back graded any higher. Too many bag marks. I think you would be best off to leave it where it is.