Morgan dollars and possible rarity??

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by John Doe, Jul 5, 2011.

  1. John Doe

    John Doe Junior Member

    Hi, so I am on vacation with my mom in Atlantic City. There are many cash for gold and coin shops. I went to one where a guy didn't know about his morgan dollars. He sells them 45$ each. There was a 1885-CC and it was in VG condition and possibly better. Yesterday I bought a 1896-o for 45 and it's in just awesome condition but has some dark spots (not black dirt spots but just darkening spots. Tell me, did I get a good deal, and should I get the 1885-CC one for $45? Thank you.Pics: sorry i am on My ipad



    http://db.tt/ucxOJS9




    http://db.tt/w32a3zu
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. redwin117

    redwin117 Junior Member

    I think you should get the 1885 CC for $ 45.. not the 1896 O.
     
  4. Taylor101

    Taylor101 New Member

    I checked my redbook and it says that the 1885- CC and goes for $500 in VF so you should have gotton the 1885-CC. For what you did get, the 1896-O , is going for $25 dollars in VF and $30 in EF. You should deffinanly get the 1885-CC! Go back and get it and post pictures! :smile
     
  5. John Doe

    John Doe Junior Member

    Okay, will do. What do you think of the quality of the 1896 one? What grade would you give it? I already bought it and I don't care if I got a bad deal because I'll buy the other one >:D
     
  6. Taylor101

    Taylor101 New Member

    Ef-40 :smile
     
  7. John Doe

    John Doe Junior Member

    Okay, he also has buffalo and roosvlt. Nickels that are silver. Should i look at those? What dates should I look for?
     
  8. redwin117

    redwin117 Junior Member

    go with 1937 D 3 legged or 1918 D 1921 S 1914 D Buffallo 1926s on roosevelt 1946- 1964.. that's all 1996 w.
     
  9. Taylor101

    Taylor101 New Member

    Well if you are not trying to fill holes in an album or coin folder, then look for what Redwin said, and also if the war nickels are priced under $2.50 dollars, then buy em all up! Same with the roosevelts ! If you are not trying to fill a whole then buy them for the silver and buy them for under $2.50 a peice. The current silver melt value is $35.10 per ounce. So make sure not to get ripped off! :smile
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page