Thanks for the opinions everyone... I agree that it is hard to judge from just pictures, you HAVE to hold the coin in hand, especially when it comes down to the high AU and MS grades, the luster is much more of a factor. I may send it to CAC just for fun to see what they think. Also, to the guy who just posted, it's a pretty new slab, the dealer I bought it from had it certified just recently, as in earlier this year.