The first is an AA token. Alcoholics Anonymous. 18 years here and happy. It is pretty common, might be worth a buck.
I don't know what the Sears token is, but I'm really impressed that it is made from "authentic material". I understand that authentic material is quite rare and valuable.
It is pretty disappointing to know that those AA tokens are common. That must mean that drunk drivers are even more common.
I know a guy who just got his 3rd DUI, I do believe that means jail time and loss of licence for 10 years. Its just not worth it...