Morgan toners.... Help please!

Do these look AT or NT to you? I think they look legit, but so many with the same colors makes me kinda leery.....


http://shop.ebay.com/american.numismatics/m.html

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Imo, they all look AT, except for the Franklin and Washington.

 

I agree with raider, the Morgans don't look right. As you say Coinsnake they're toning is too similar. Everything else looks ok to me.

Bruce

 

Not only do they have similar colors but their overall toning pattern is to similar as well. AT

 

Horrible job of faking with exception of the 1898 which is more than likely AT but could pass if not surrounded by all of the other AT'd coins

 

I imagine that there are a couple that could be deemed as market acceptable.
Although, any seller that has a bulk of raw toned coins with quite a few having similar toning patterns, should set off a few red flags as to the originality of the toning.

 

All appear AT to me... those that don't are AT by association imo.