Which Morgan to keep..... Help please!

I need to sell one of these, but can't decide which one. They're both 1887 Philadelphias. I want to keep the nicer one for myself. The first one I'll post has a better strike with more numerous but smaller marks.







The second coin has weaker strike with very few marks, but the marks are deeper. This second coin has outstanding luster.





I love both, but need the cash. Any help/comments are appreciated. Thank you.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I like the top one better so mabye keep that one...ya on second look def. sell bottom one if any at all (I hate it when I sell coins bec, I need the money )

 

It's really hard to tell from those pictures but I'd say the bottom one as the Luster is Silky Smooth

 

That's the one I was leaning towards, but it's got the deeper marks and a weaker strike.... Damn I hate selling!!!! RRRRRR

 

The second just looks cleaner to me, I think Id keep that one. Sorry u need to sell either one.

 

I would keep the one on the bottom as well. Question: Why does it look like both have blue toning?

 

I either need to sell one of these or one of my three 1891 CCs so I guess I'll bite the bullet on one of these.

 

Blue is lighting I think.
And if I can't see the marks he talks about with those picts but from what I see again the bottom.

 

Oh you should sell the 91CC's...you have 3 and I need one

 

Nice countertop.

I'd sell the bottom one.

 

Now we have the same dilemma with those. Two of them are spitting eagle VAMs and all 3 of them are in the same condition (XF-AU). I don't think I'll be able to sell them at this time.

 

Merc Crazy, I think that is a RUG lol
And no...sell me the 91CC

 

It's carpet btw.

 

I'd keep the second. More of an "original" luster to it. First has probably been dipped longer/more times.

 

There's a reptile tank in the room and the lights are that color. Both coins are BRIGHT white. 1st has small gold toning at 11 o'clock.

 

I am sorry you need to sell one. But it's good that you have a duplicate. It really sucks when you have to sell the only ones you have, but that is one reason we buy the gold & silver coins...........insurance. If currency won;t get it done, gold or silver will.

Wishing you well and hope that the situation improves soon.

Gary

 

+1

 

Could you guys give me a grade estimate on these. I was thinking at least 63, maybe 64 on the bottom coin. What do you think? Are either 65s?

 

Again from those dark pict's it tough but I'll say the top is 63 and the bottom 64.

 

sell the python instead !