Guess the GD grade nitwit grade and real grade

The Silver Rupees I have don't seem to have the luster the US Coins do. I do not know if that is because of the additional metal composition or something in the minting process itself. Also the detail on the Crown and medals is weakly striken. The minting process seems not as precise as that of Canada, Europe and the US. I think this is MS63 ? I don't think the coin was ever in circulation.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Nitwits: Ms-66

Dougs: Au-58

My stab at it (another nitwit): Ms-64

 

grandpa youa re confused i have never looked at that coin in my life. i have also never bought it raw or sent it to ngc myself. i just bought it a few hours before i posted it. i should get a gold coin from you just for thinking it was one of my older coins.

thats why we love you you are so cute when you make these little speeches

but surely youa dmit you are better than both ngc and pcgs combined dont you?

 

ok now GD we will work towards part 2 of your conversion that the TPG are done and dusted with

i now submit to you toning is the firt step towards corrosion if left unchecked and in so coins with toning should be discounted and not sold at a premium.

now many will jump at this and cal it sacrilege and i understand that but everywhere in the antique business any form of decay does not bring you premium. i am not trying to stir a hornets nest here just trying to make grandpa see the light

he scoffed at me when i told him that ngc and pcgs were going through a decline

he scoffed at me when i told him he could grade better than both of them ( and GD you would be daft to think i would not consult you before buying coins only a fool would not and take a TPG word instead but at an average of about 3k per coin they were about 500 -1000 not forty eleven thousand besides there is no such thing dont be greenoculous )


being stuck in the western world for the last 2k years has made him see things from a certain prism
but then i am spock and for better or worse he has the job of being my guardian angel

i am just trying to get him to see a different world

 

there is the whole piece about being able to judge a coin from an imperfect photograph. you listeneing eh GD

 

bravo so harvey finally stopped laughing?

 

oh i forgot i cant give the grade away right now grandpa some of the members are still playing

 

oh grandpa my 150 yr post coin is destrooyed by the vandals at the mint

 

so, are we ever going to find out the grade????

 

it has been well documented through hundreds of scores of dollars that you are better than both combined. there is no need to be modest for the one quality you do have

 

ill post the grade on sunday all 3 my doug grade will be hilarious

 

i almost fell of my chair when i read this post i wa slaughing so hard

its still not too late to change your avatar to GD -58

 

its a work in progress by 2020 i will have you converted i am going to start putting some light in tomorrow we will use paintings manuscripts sculptures paper money and stamps before yu are ready for coins. we hav eto detox and de train you first. trust me it will be your second coming

 

it just dawned on me that we are two sides of the same coin and we cannot have this disagreement between us. i am sorry but i will be forced to convert you now

 

Did I miss something here? I never learned the grade(s) either.

 

K im not part of the "old gang" but ill give it a shot anyway.
Nitwit: 64
GD: he already told us Au 58 though im surprised its that high.
My grade: I would grade it an MS 62

 

No such thing as a good ole boys club here. Actually, everyones a good ole boy (or girl )

Hey Spock, Collect & Mike are right. What was the grade? If it were up to me I'd let it slide, but Harvey keeps pestering me.....