Guess the GD grade nitwit grade and real grade

ok, here's my attempt:

Nitwits say MS-70

Doug says AU-58

Real Grade is MS-65

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Nitwits say MS-70

Doug says MS-62

Real Grade is PF-65

 

This is a large coin like a USA half or silver dollar right? There are 2 million business stikes & some number of proofs struck for collectors. I don't see any contact marks or luster. This is why I guessed some grade of proof manufacture.

 

Actually he was around before the snake.

 

Harvey is laughing so hard he can't enter a grade....nit wit or otherwise.

 

you on the other hand my friend are free to do so

 

GD to adam and eve after they have eaten the appple

dont you guys look before you buy stuff?
that wa sa rotten apple
now we will have coins as a result
and most of my daylight hours will vanish repeating stuff about coins
what a tragedy

Adam and eve reply but it was the snakes fault

GD starts running after the snake the snake on seeing GD tries to do everything but cant avoid him so he finally becomes a gold ducat and GD falls in love

 

its 30.5 mm

 

1. Ms-64
2. Doug's, cleaned, flip scraps, grading is a gamble and varies to much, but if I have to AU,58
3. Ms-62

 

I thought nitwit was like NGC since he mentioned them grading incorrectly? So yes some clarity might make me change my guesses - well not the last two.

 

If the Nitwit is NGC, then I might change my Nitwit grade to SP-63. I am all over the place with this coin photo. It could be AU, MS, SP, PF (or even have an impaired obverse surface). I look forward to knowing the NGC opinion.

 

nitwit is whoever you want it to be. it could be a fool it could also be ngc if you think of them as nitwits who am i to argue. The real grade is the actual grade of the coin not by ngc or pcgs but what the actual coin is in their opinion


i must say u have really started acting like the grand vizier in your second innings i am proud of you

 

yes the coin is an ngc holder but since when have they had an opinion that was worth anything? we are lucky if they can spot the difference between fake and real and extremely grateful if they can get the century and denomination right as far as indian coins go.

 

unfortunately pcgs is equally bad when it comes to indian coins

 

1. 65
2. 58
3. 64

 

this is purely my take:

nitwit grade: a grade that would be given by a novice, probably not at all accurate.

Doug's grade: something a crusty, old, and jaded numismatist would conservatively (maybe overly so) grade it

real grade: what most TPGs would grade it (accurate or not)

and the correct answers are all according to Spock!!!

dig your way out of this king spock!!!

LOL

 

you are looking for king spock? we will let you know once we find him. i am now galactic emperor

gurards someone go and press the little button and put mike out of his misery

well tpgs can grade indian coins mike we have already established that but if u include them in the nitwit grade then you can compare them to the slab and see where you stand

doug is 10 times better than the TPG's even at his age

 

not to mention lack of experience and expertise and drawback in not being able to read the language