Washington 1932 S- opinions on the grade?

This coin has been graded by PCGS. I would like your opinions on the grade before I revealed their grade.
Thank you

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Doug
Would you please enlighten me as to why you would think it is un-gradeable?
Thanks

 

Damaged? Because of a nick on the cheek? lol

AU 55ish, IMO.

 

MS-63??they have to grade 3 side of the coin.
I see larger scratches on MS-64

 

'Tis but a flesh wound.

MS62.

 

p.s. DLRC scans suck.

 

The fact that he said it has been graded is what leads me to guess it's an MS62 instead of being slabbed genuine. However, taking into account that most people who make a thread here asking what the grade of their coin probably is are usually unhappy with the assigned grade, I should probably revise that to AU58 or 55.

 

Most of thoses coins were cleaned

 

Yes, it was graded. In this case, I am not unhappy with the grade assigned by PGCS. I will post the grade this evening.

 

I say MS-61

 

You guys are better than me. I really can't accurately grade this coin from those photos but if I had to guess, MS62 sounds about right. I like the reverse.

While the scratch is distracting and certainly will affect the grade of the coin, there is no way that scratch should result in a body bag. I have seen much worse on many a graded coin.

 

62

 

Amen to that brother. I have a thread that I am working on that discusses that very issue. Stay tuned!

 

Au-58

 

I cannot tell for sure whether it is a 55 or a 62. From your comments, I would assume you got the 55.