Hi all, So I have this coin, an 1839 Seated quarter. its a solid AU-55 piece with AMAZING PL surfaces, Only one problem a certain TPG called the OBV improperly cleaned. And in my expert opinion it has not been improperly cleaned, theres not any hairlines to suggest it was nor has it been over dipped. I would love to have it holdered but i guess it won't happen. What should I do? try to cut my loses or keep this unique piece that doesn't have a place in my high grade slabbed set? or maybe sell it?
I had this happen only once with my mercs.......I am 100 percent sure it is not a problem coin but I understand that u dont want to keep spending and trying.......I lucked out becaus e it was an early die crack and I keep those........maybe try the other grading company
It's really up to you but I'd keep it as TPG'ers opinions change from year to year. Plus you seem to like it. But I dont keep my set's all organized like some of you do. I also think a picture of it would help
They can change from week to week. There have been many, many reports of coins being bagged as harshly cleaned, re-submitted the day after the owner got them back, and the coins were then slabbed.
