Walking Liberty up for Grading

Working on my grading skills. Figured I'd put them up to the test on this walking liberty. Offer your opinion on what grade you think it is. I have my own, just wanted to see if they jive with what others think.

Both sets are the same coin. The first picture is with a phone camera, the next is scanned.

Thanks!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'm thinking somewhere around fine to very fine. I looks like most of the wing feathers are in tact.

 

Definitely VF, in my opinion.

 

VF20-VF25 Reverse is VF25 Obverse is choice VF20 so it could go anyway

 

Its good that you are walking her up rather than driving.

 

F-15 to VF-20

 

My only slabbed coin is a VF-20 '34-S Walker in an old ANACS holder... doesn't look quite as nice, so I'll go with VF-25.

 

F15

 

Vf 22.5 (i.e. I can't decide between 20 and 25)

 

Vf-20. Tc

 

Both are VF.

 

F-15 to VF 20. Although, as they say on EBay, "I'm not a professional grader. This is my opinion only"

 

Vf20

 

The damage to the rim, 2 O'clock on the reverse would preclude it from grading at one or more of the major houses.

Now if you would just like a grade, that's OK.

Very Fine 20 both sides, but a net grade of Fine 15 due to post mint damage.

(but then again, I am very critical when it comes to Walkers)

Happy Collecting

 

VF20 based on what I have seen.

 

Thanks to everybody that threw in their two cents. Feel free to anybody else that hasn't.

I was thinking VF myself. Wanted to put it up for opinion to see how other's thought and get a feel if I was on the mark or not.

Thanks!

 

I agree it is in the F to VF range (as most of mine are) but thats a tough call between the two for me because I have a long way to go when grading Walkers. Nice Walker by the way.

 

For what it's worth, here's my 34-S, rotated in the holder..