CoinTalk's BEST COIN GRADERS (from pics)-5

Round 5...

I'll update rankings from round 4 after the last regular submits, was a challenging round and in fairness we'll postpone. However, also want to give the group something to ponder this weekend, per schedule... here't is!

I'll only rank those who played in the last round.

Dropped score after every 16th.
Dropped scores this week.
Leadfoot - drops lowest:hail:
Lehigh - drops lowest:hail:
Raider - drops lowest:hail:
RLM's - drops lowest:hail:
Badthad - drops lowest:hail:
bigjpst - drops lowest:hail:
Duke - drops lowest:hail:

Gotta have at least 10 graded to rank.

Rankings (points reflect average grades off tpg grades):
GOLD - Raider / Duke - 1.00 > tied
SILVER - Lehigh - 1.07
BRONZE - Rlm's - 1.27
and now the Pack:
4th - Bigjpst - 1.33
5th - BadThad / Leadfoot - 1.40
6th - BQcoints - 1.42
7th - Swish - 1.50
** expect more dynamics in the rankings after everyone scores thier 1st dropped score after this round.


Gonna throw out some hodgepodge this round since we have two rounds pending now...

TPG's this round:
ANACS - 1955
ANI - 1986 - yeah, ANI, whoever they are..,, take a stab at it if your confident you know the tpg's grading style.... or leave blank if you don't want to. Will be graded only if you offer a grade,,,, could help your overall grade, or hurt it,,, know thy tpg.
PCGS - 2006
NGC - 1972

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Next one

 

And finally:

 

baha, ANI or the American Numismatic Institute and UGS Universal Grading Service (same company two names) are now defunct. But as not even a 3rd tier company, I would argue that every grader here is better than what amounted to probably a self slabber. How is anyone going to come close on this ugly coin, now if you posted an SGS coin I'd just say MS70.

 

,, I picked it up at a show years ago for bullion and didn't care about the holder or grade.... figured I'd throw it out to the group as a bonus. It's the only coin I can remember seeing from this tpg,,, figured that it some of ya'll knew thier grading style it would be an easy one to grade.

Anyway, to the question,, I don't really know,,, maybe a brief internet search would provide clues.

Worst case, don't grade it,,, It will only count to your score if you offer a grade.

 

1955 ms-63
1986 gonna say ANI said ms70 guess it couldn't hurt I'm already in last place
2006 ms69
1972 pf69

 

1955 ms63
1986 au
2006 ms69
1972 ms70

 

1955- ms62
1986- not going to try
2006- ms69
1972- pf68

 

1955 - MS63
1986 - skip
2006 - MS69
1972S - PF68

 

I will play, the jefferson I would think would be a 62, lots of hits, I would give the 86 silver eagle a 66 you do not see too many of them that dinged,but I think ani might be one of those buy a grade companies. the 2006 eagle should be about a 67 or 8, I will go with 67. The wq I think would go pf-65

 

1955 - MS-64
1986 - xxxx
2006 - MS-69
1972S - PF-67 UC

 

1955 ms63
1986 ms69
2006 ms69
1972 pf69

​

 

Ms63
ms69
ms68
pf67 cameo

 

1 - MS63
2 - MS68 - looks like it is starting to form spots.
3 - MS69
4 - PR-68

 

1955 Jefferson ANACS - MS64
1986 ASE ANI - MS69
2006 ASE PCGS- MS69 (First Strike that' part is obvious)
1972 Wash NGC - PR-68UC (if there is a DC grade that doesn't count cause NGC gives UC )

 

1955 - 64
1986 - 70
2006 - 69
72 - 67

 

55-MS-65
2006 MS-69
1972 PR-68 Cameo and maybe a Star?

 

Bump for Leadfoot....

 

:whistle:

 

I find the term "Leadfoot" as funny as if walking a lead foot would make you very slow but in driving it's very fast.

With Leadfoot taking his time on this one I'd say he's a walking, aka Walking Liberty that is!!

This is just an elaborate way of saying:

BUMP