Poll: "In God We Trust" on coins?

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by se-collectibles, Apr 7, 2010.

?

Should "In God We Trust" be on US coins?

  1. Yes

    122 vote(s)
    65.6%
  2. No

    51 vote(s)
    27.4%
  3. No Opinion

    13 vote(s)
    7.0%
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. se-collectibles

    se-collectibles Collector Extraordinaire

    Deference in what respect?
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. Marshall

    Marshall Junior Member

    Just as today, some object to having the motto on the coins, some would have seen the portrait of Liberty as promoting (as opposed to acknowledging a classic art form) a belief in pagan Gods. The fact that most people didn't associate the portrait with honoring a pagan goddess would not be relevant to the objectors.
     
  4. se-collectibles

    se-collectibles Collector Extraordinaire

    Do you any references to back that up?
     
  5. Marshall

    Marshall Junior Member

    I have no specific references to this, but a good handle on the nature of people in general and specifically to those who are pius. Do you have any references which refute this?
     
  6. se-collectibles

    se-collectibles Collector Extraordinaire

    It's next to impossible to prove a negative. In any case, I never made a claim to know what people were thinking 235 years ago.

    Edit: that should be 223... i was thinking Declaration not Constitution
     
  7. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    Ahhh - so I'm being arrogant by stating something that is true. Well, if that's the case then I guess I am arrogant.


    I freely admit that the use of the word God would not include the pagans. And there is a lot more than just the Hindus. Oh and by the way, you can't count the Buddhist, the Buddhist have no gods.

    Never once have I said anything about believing any facts about God. What I have commented on are facts about relgions. There is a huge difference between the two.

    I never said it could be, I merely said I disagreed with you.

    Not at all. But I do think that you are misinterpretting Jefferson. You are choosing to interpret it to mean that the state can never use any reference to God. What Jefferson meant was that there was never to be any state relgion.

    As I have said all along, and this what none of you can seem to get past . The wall of separation that Jeffrson intended was between the state and religion, not between the state and God. God and religion are two entirely separate and different things.

    Most people don't think that. But then that is because most people actually know very little about the various religions. They have little or no understanding at all as to what the beliefs of the various religions actually are.

    You come pretty close to proving my point for me with that comment. For you see, that has always been one of the primary reasons for all of the war and strife caused by relgion throughout history. It is precisely because they worship the same God that the various relgions always fought against each other. They are all convinced that all of the others do it wrong, that only their way is right. And so those who are wrong should be punished and forced to do it their way. They consider the practice of other relgions as blasphemy and an affront to their God because the other religion's God is their God.
     
  8. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    I can show you some references, try reading what you find at the following link. Oh, and by the way, there are still those who object to it today. Click Here
     
  9. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    Now let me try something a little bit different, let's put the shoe on the other foot. And thanks to Marhsall for the idea.

    For all of those who believe that the use of the motto on our money should be stopped because it is unconstitutional, or that is does not adhere to a separation of church and state - should we then remove any and all references of pagan gods or goddesses from state property ?

    I mean, state buildings like courthouses are no longer allowed to have nativity scenes on the lawn at Christmas time because of the religious conotations.

    It has been claimed in this thread that swearing to God, or swearing on the bible in court is no longer permitted for the same reasons.

    But yet our money was at one time adorned with a pagan goddess. Many of our state buildings all over the nation, even our Capitol building in Washington, is adorned with staues of pagan godddesses. Some state flags have pagan goddesses on them. The Statue of Liberty is a statue of a pagan goddess. Many of our courthouses, the Supreme Court building itself has a statue of a pagan goddess right in front.

    Of course all of these things are some of the most sacred, some of the most strongly believed in, and some of the most precious symbols of our nation that we have.

    So should, by the same reasoning that you claim that the motto should be removed from our money - should all of these national and state symbols be removed ? Should the Statue of Liberty be torn down and destroyed ?

    All of these things, by your reasoning, absolutely depict images of relgions and religious symbols. Pagan relgions, but religions just the same.

    So how do you answer that ?
     
  10. swish513

    swish513 Penny & Cent Collector

    so many people assume they are one in the same. it's sad.
     
  11. cladking

    cladking Coin Collector

    Great point.

    There's one tiny flaw though; there's no longer a church. These are no longer organized religions.
     
  12. se-collectibles

    se-collectibles Collector Extraordinaire

    Symbols are representations of concepts, ideas and ideals. Money does not exist, it is a concept, and coins are the symbols of that concept.

    I don't have a problem with symbols, pagan or otherwise. The ideals behind some symbols is a different matter.
     
  13. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    Really ? So no one still worships these ancient gods ? There is information to the contrary if you care to look it up.
     
  14. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    So would you have a problem if there was a statue of Jesus on our Capitol building ?
     
  15. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    If you find this so hard to believe clad, then perhaps you should read the Koran sometime -

    "ALLAH is HE besides Whom there is none worthy of worship, the Living, the Self-Subsisting and All-Sustaining. HE has sent down to thee the Book containing the truth and fulfilling that which precedes it; and HE has sent down the Torah (Law of Moses) and the Gospel (of Jesus) before this, as a guidance to the people; and HE has sent down the Discrimination (judgement between right and wrong)."—Qur'an, Surah 3:3-4
     
  16. Moen1305

    Moen1305 Mysticism and Tyrants

    The Statue of Liberty is NOT a pagan goddess. It is a woman with different aspects of Greek mythical characters. To answer the broader question, I don't care if it is Christianity, Paganism, Judaism, Atheism, or any other belief system currently being practiced or even if it was a religious belief of the past; our government should not be promoting it in any way.
     
  17. se-collectibles

    se-collectibles Collector Extraordinaire

    Jesus is iconic of Christian faith whether he was a real person or not, and not simply a generic symbol.

    What's interesting is, even though Jesus is normally thought of as only a Christian icon, Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism and Sikhism all acknowledge Jesus, though in different ways.

    I do not know if Jesus was actually a living man or is simply the embodiment of something long forgotten, but I cannot say that I would have a problem with a statue of Jesus on the Capitol as long as the statue is not representative of a single religion.

    As an example, the Supreme Court building is replete with what could be considered pagan symbols, inside and out. I suppose there are those who would like to tear it down and put up a sterile building, get rid of swearing on the Bible, even the prayer they have before each session, which since 1789 has been led by a Christian chaplain (according to snopes.com).

    I'm not religious, honestly I don't understand a lot about it, but I respect the freedom to worship in one's own way. Maybe that's why I don't have a problem with saying "Merry Christmas" or crosses or the Cross of David being in public places.

    One thing I don't like is "political correctness". "Happy holidays" is fine, but to force people to say that instead of "Merry Christmas" is ludicrous In My Not So Humble Opinion.

    Edit: I would also have to say that it depends on the intent behind the symbol. The swastika is a symbol of the 3rd Reich - I would have a problem with it being displayed because of that.
     
  18. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    So does that mean that you think all depictions of - Liberty, Columbia & Freedom all of whom are the Roman goddess Libertas; the blind goddess of Justice who is the Greek goddess Themis, and there are plenty of other statues to go along with these but these are the two most common - should be removed from all city, county, state and federal buildings - or anything else having to do with government or our money ?

    A simple yes or no will do.

    And if you don't believe that Liberty is a pagan goddess - then you better look it up, because she is.
     
  19. Darkhorse

    Darkhorse Junior Member

    The usage of classical themes is allegorical. Biblical themes can be used as allegory, such as on the Supreme Court building where it's used in concert with other classical, secular and other religious themes.

    Those that may have a problem with a classical depiction of liberty with a phrygian cap may have a problem with idolatry all together.
     
  20. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    I submit to you that a statue of Jesus is no more iconic than a statue of Libertas or Themis. But it seems you are beginning to get the idea.

    And I guess that is the point I am, have been, trying to get across. That we have many things in our country that undeniably depict various religious icons - but yet all these people who have such a huge problem with a one little three letter word, just a word mind you, that is used on our money, in our National Anthem, and in our Pledge of Allegiance - have no problem whatsoever with these pagan statues that are literally all over the place.
     
  21. imrich

    imrich Supporter! Supporter

    Excellent Rebutals!!

    I totally agree with your "arguments", and couldn't have presented pro/con discussion in any better form. I believe your presentation throughout this thread to be "Par Excellence". Kudos!!! :high5:
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page