GTG and Selling Price. 1884o Morgan Dollar

Ok, this is a double guess. Please guess the grade and selling price. If you know from following auctions, let’s keep it secret. I do have a history with this coin, and will do the backstory in the reveal.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I can see MS 66 and will guess around $5,000
(could be more with recent pricing...note: I have not seen this coin...it might be in an auction I haven't looked at yet)

 

Guessing 65
I wonder if PCGS called it Qu
estionable Coloring.
I have no idea pricing on toners like this.

 

MS65
$1,000

I really have no idea with the toning though. Pure guess

 

About $500 ( pcgs pricing) . past auctions. Just an estimate though. I could be wrong .

 

MS64. No guess on the price. Toning can make people spend too much money.

 

Grade: 65, price: something stupid

 

64+
$1,300

Nice obverse toning. But it’s another toned Morgan…Woo!

 

MS64 with a color bump to 65+ and the sky is the limit.

 

@CamaroDMD @Skyman @Lehigh96

 

MS65
$900

 

I’m at MS65. Price, no clue but I’m gonna guess $1650.

 

Reveal tonight.

 

MS65

 

@jtlee321 @ldhair @Lehigh96
@mrweaseluv @Paddy54 @eddiespin @KSorbo @ddoomm1
@MIGuy

 

I'd call her a 63* that dink on the bottom of the eagles right wing (left side) is gonna hold it back if not detail it... Looks like nice "old album" toning to me so I don't think there's much chance of AT so I gave her the star... Without the dink on the wing I might call it 65 but it really catches and holds my eye...
Now price... Hmm I'd call it probably around 750-800 hammer price
Unless you were the most recent buyer then I would bring it down to 550-600

 

How did I miss this beauty!! I would guess MS-65 and $3750.00.

 

66

 

Ok, when I bought this coin in 2008, it was a MS 65, in an OGH. I remember paying $200 for it, but I really liked the fireball toning. My opinion was that it was appropriately graded. I sold it in my big toner sale as a 65 OGH for $900, in 2018, to a private buyer.

back in 2020, I believe it was resold for $1200, in the same holder. A few weeks ago I was researching toned sales on eBay, Great Collections, and Heritage, and found this:



Was I surprised by a 66+ grade CAC in a reholder? Yes, as I thought the 65 was appropriate. The sale price, as one can see, was $2499. So, the upgrade paid off, although I think that quality of toning could have sold for a higher price.

 

@Morgandude11 I looked at GC and noticed that coin has sold 4 times in the span of about 4 years (all in the 66+ holder)!

1) $1,096.88 (Dec 2018)
https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/641004/1884-O-Morgan-Silver-Dollar-PCGS-MS-66-CAC-Toned

2) $3,262.50 (Sep 2019)...this is the max it reached
https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/749781/1884-O-Morgan-Silver-Dollar-PCGS-MS-66-CAC-Toned

3) $1,687.50 (Nov 2020)
https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/910457/1884-O-Morgan-Silver-Dollar-PCGS-MS-66-CAC-Toned

4) $1,630.79 (Nov 2021)
https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/1070069/1884-O-Morgan-Silver-Dollar-PCGS-MS-66-CAC-Toned