1889 S Morgan guess the grade

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

MS64 today, MS63 on the label..Very nice '89-s...

 

65

 

I call it a 65. If the label says 64, you got robbed. Beautiful coin!

 

I don't care if the label says less, that is a great looking MS65

 

I need to work on my Morgan skills. I would call that a strong MS65 all day long. If it weren't for the bump on Lady Liberty's cheek, I would call it a 66. A fellow could get lost in that luster....

 

MS65 edging into a 66 maybe, very nice original luster.. with a few less bag marks I would say 66 easy but they holding her back

 

only flaw I see is a scratch by the 1 I'll go MS 66 and a beautiful nearing $1200 coin? I see no label #'s?

 

I would give it a 66 but for the chatter on the obverse, especially the face, it may have been knocked down.

 

Oh that's rockin! Easy gem. MS66 might be pushing it but I like it at MS66.

 

MS65 here.
Nice date too.

 

64

 

Stunning. I’d go with 64+ and the small mark near her mouth prevents the 65

 

Excellent photos btw

 

I'm on the fence with this one. I like it as a 65, but I think they may have called it a 64. Really lovely Morgan!!

 

MS-65, looking mighty nice.

 

What do you think the "bump" may be? Before considering, view the ear a little closer, and the lip.(Tip: hold a 5X up to the screen).

I do not think the "bump" will be viewed as a negative by a TPG.

My opinion....usually wrong.

 

That was a good lesson, Charley and I appreciate that….. My initial reaction was a bag hit. Looking closer now, I believe that may be a minor die crack or perhaps a scratch in the die. That appears now to be a raised line on her cheek…. Thanks for the lesson.

 

A few nicks and bruises but otherwise good luster, a very nice Morgan. MS-63 thanks for sharing, hope it's better!

 

Really nice coin. I'd say 65. Is there a die crack behind the head?