GTG 1971 Dollar #2

What do you feel PCGS gave this?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I liked #1 a bit better...that one seems to have better luster and has a few less hits...something here makes me say MS 64

 

Love the toning on the obverse. I would concur with MS 64.

 

More images.

 

ms65

 

MS65

 

MS 64

 

MS64

 

The additional pictures are better. It is on the edge between 64 and 65. Probably a 64+. The important thing distinguishing the coin is the beautiful color.

 

Depends on what you paid for. LOL

 

MS-63

 

I'm thinking AU. Appears to have some wear and was rubbed between UNITED and the globe. Could be polishing marks but still at AU.

 

65, but questionable color.

 

Agreed, questionable color but 64.

 

This one is difficult. I'm guessing AU50's, hope I'm wrong I like Ike's.

 

64,
Not my series at all, but blue and purple toning always makes me question.....

 

I still view it as 65 compared to others...the toning doesn't help it any.

 

The gap between MS 64 and MS 65 is the hardest for TPGs to get right. I find that they tend to make their mistakes in the jump from high BU (64) to gem (65). Sometimes, graders are reluctant, especially when there is a big price jump involved. To me, this coin is clearly a 65, but PCGS played it quite conservatively.

 

Agreed...this is the spot where a "+" can make a big difference without tipping the scale.