I hate to say it but the 1912-D looks whizzed. The grainy texture in the large images all over including the rims is what I notice.
Personally, I would return the Barber, it looks harshly cleaned/. Although you say it looks fine in hand. Good luck
Nice haul grasshopper. Cleaned or not, if you didn't pay the price in the picture, you did well and a keeper, IMHO.