An interesting error antoninianus of Probus from Lugdunum

Discussion in 'Ancient Coins' started by Harry G, Aug 12, 2021.

  1. Harry G

    Harry G Well-Known Member

    Hi all!

    I recently bought this antoninianus of Probus on eBay. It is from Lugdunum mint, and it has an interesting spelling mistake in it. Instead of reading "TEMPOR FELICI", it just reads "TEMPR FELICI", omitting the O.

    probus tempr felici.png

    The seller didn't mention the error in the description, and said that it was just a "TEMPOR FELICI" type. I managed to buy it (having paid a lot more for it than my other Probus coins lol)

    The coin also came with some nice provenance, having apparently been part of the Linchmere Hoard, which was found way back in 1924. However, the seller didn't provide any proof in the listing, so I tried to find some.

    I found an old analysis of the Hoard off Jstor, and went to the page where it listed all the types. Surprisingly, my coin was not there; the only similar coins were 10 TEMPOR FELICI types

    linchmere hoard-min.png
    When the coin arrived today, the seller was kind enough to provide information about where it came from. It turns out a lot of the coins found in the Linchmere Hoard that the landowner was allowed to keep were auctioned back in May 2021 from an auction house that didn't specialise in coins:

    https://www.lawrences.co.uk/sales/fine-art-sales/fc270521/view-lot/888/

    Lot 888
    ANTONINIANUS OF PROBUS 276-282. Radiate bust r. within legend IMP C PROBUS P F AUG. Reverse female figure of Felicitas holding cornucopiae and caduceus within TEMPOR FELICI. Mint mark I for Gaul. Webb records 133 coins from this reign amongst the hoard, 10 with the legend Tempor Felici to the reverse. Provenance: The Linchmere Hoard, Miss Abbott and thence by descent.
    Estimate: £20 - £30
    Sold for £30.00

    (It looks like I spent more than double what the seller I bought it from paid lol)

    It looks like the auction house also misdescribed the coin, and that it did indeed come from the Linchmere Hoard.

    Show me some error coins, or some coins with nice provenance!
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. furryfrog02

    furryfrog02 Well-Known Member

    Perhaps the engraver was using some artistic license and the top of the caduceus as the "O" :)
     
  4. maridvnvm

    maridvnvm Well-Known Member

    I was wondering when if this one might emerge. I was the underbidder. It is not the only die with this reverse error I have one from a different die pair with a different reverse legend break.

    [​IMG]
     
  5. barnaba6

    barnaba6 Well-Known Member

    Great addition! Congratulations! Here are my error Probus coins:

    https://www.colleconline.com/en/col...imperial-probus-erroneous-obv-and-rev-legends

    including also a TEMPR FELICI coin, from yet another reverse die:

    https://www.colleconline.com/en/items/127083/coin-ancient-b-to-a-roman-tempr-felici

    On first glance some might say there is a "ghost" visible of the letter "O" before the caduceus but I checked the coin closely under magnifying glass and it is not the case. There is no trace of the letter "O" there at all.
     
    Harry G likes this.
  6. barnaba6

    barnaba6 Well-Known Member

    Probus had many more error coins. It's always a pleasure to find one of them.
     
    Harry G likes this.
  7. Harry G

    Harry G Well-Known Member

    Oops, sorry about that. I wouldn't have bought it if I'd have known another forum member was going to bid

    Woah, those coins are amazing! I like the "PRBVS" one.

    No, I can't see any trace of an O either. It seems Probus is one of the most mis-spelled emperors :)
     
  8. Claudius_Gothicus

    Claudius_Gothicus Well-Known Member

    Very nice coin, especially considering the provenance! Errors on antoniniani are still quite rare, though more common than on other denominations, and sometimes can be quite interesting, especially when they alter an emperor's name. For example, there are some coins of Claudius II where his name is misspelled as either Cladius or Caudius. Here's an example of the latter:

    IMP C CAVDIVS AVG (sic) - CONSER AVG.jpg
    Claudius II (268-270), Antoninianus, Antioch mint.
    Obverse: IMP C CAVDIVS AVG (sic), radiate head left;
    Reverse: CONS-ER AVG, Serapis standing right, with right hand raised and holding transverse sceptre in left hand, facing Isis standing left, holding sistrum in right hand and bucket in left hand.
    RIC V 202, RIC V Online 1080

    The only other example I could find was an obverse die match in the Gysen collection, illustrated on the same page.
     
  9. Roman Collector

    Roman Collector Well-Known Member

    Engraving the letters backwards onto a die is hard.

    ƧABINA AVGVSTA -- this is "Sabina-1" in my collection, purchased at a brick and mortar coin shop in 1998.

    [​IMG]
     
  10. Harry G

    Harry G Well-Known Member

    You've reminded me of this coin I bought recently. It's not as impressive as your Sabina, but it's an antoninianus of Gallienus, PAX AVG reverse. The mintmark is supossed to be S-I, but the engraver has done Ƨ-I instead

    gallienus pax avg s i retrograde.png
     
  11. Andres2

    Andres2 Well-Known Member

  12. PeZet123

    PeZet123 New Member

    Hi! I was 3rd underbidder. Haha ;)
     
  13. Harry G

    Harry G Well-Known Member

    Small world lol
     
  14. PeZet123

    PeZet123 New Member

    I wanted to bid on 100 pounds ;) But... At the end of the day I am happy that this coin "landed" in your collection ;)
     
  15. Harry G

    Harry G Well-Known Member

    Ah, I guess I had an advantage there then. I'm in the UK, so the postage costs were negligible for me.

    I'll let you know if I ever plan to sell it, although I'm not planning to for the moment I'm afraid
     
  16. PeZet123

    PeZet123 New Member

    Thanks! Let me know immediately ;)
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page