Great looking coin. I think I would have kept the 1893-S but it would be a difficult choice. At least your collection is now complete.
I could have done both. I sold the ‘93s out of choice. I saw no reason to own a $20,000+ key coin AU 50, that was really not particularly attractive, just for the sake of owning it. I much more enjoy my common date MS 67 or 67+ Morgans, than the 93s, just because it is a way overvalued key date.