1943 steel pulled from a roll - original clad or reprocessed?

Hey all this steel showed up in a roll of wheats I went through a couple days ago. I thought it was incredible luck but after seeing this thread on reprocessed steels:
https://www.cointalk.com/threads/damaged-of-course-but-exactly-how.381774/
I'm wondering if that's why this was in the roll (maybe somebody got scammed and tossed it into circulation?)



The edge has a few spots of rust, but not near what I would expect from a circulation 1943. Maybe the rust is leaching through the coating?

On the other hand, maybe this was stored well for years and then recently spent by a grandchild or something.

I'm 75% convinced this is reprocessed, but thought I'd run it by you guys and get a second opinion. Thanks for any thoughts.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Guessing real.

 

Real as Mayonnaise !

 

It looks like it has its original surfaces. Nice find.

 

Wow, glad I got second opinions. That'll teach me to pre-judge coins.

Thanks guys!

 

A total of 684,628,000 Steel Cents were minted at the Philadelphia Mint. I wouldn't consider that rare.
It is neat finding one in such good condition.

 

It's a good one. AU. Nice features on it.

 

Original surfaces. The reprocessed ones are bright and shiny.

Just to show how numismatic retailing has changed, I used to see many ads in the magazines for reprocessed PDS sets of these coins. They are worth so little these days, no dealer would waste his advertising money.

 

ya done good

 

Good eye!

 

Yeah, I should rephrase the incredible luck as unexpected luck. Apparently entirely credible given the numbers.

The good condition was what surprised me. Under the microscope it's not great, but just eyeballing it, it gleams among the corroded brown wheat cents it arrived with.

 

Did the steel pennies themselves drop in value as well or just the reprocessed sets?

 

It does not have the look of a reprocessed cent. I have some steel cents that I purchased a few years ago at my LCS. They cost me 6 for $1.00. Not rare, not reprocessed but the real thing.

 

lol, ok. Well I suppose I cut my $6 roll of wheat cost down to $5.84.
Luckily I'm planning for this hobby to need funding instead of acting as funding.

 

A very wise decision.

 

These were cosmetic things. Some people went for them, some still do. Suppose when you put them together in a set they seem like they're more important. They never had value to collectors, though, as they're just messed with.

 

I must disagree. In the photo that shows the edge, you can enlarge it and see that the zinc is continuous in some area with the face surfaces almost a 1/4 or 1/3 the way to the center of the rim. The mint zinc would only be a small line for the facings as no zinc was added to rims. Hard to tell from photo, but that's my thought. Sorry Jim

 

No worries, I would not be surprised if this was ultimately the case. Is there a better angle or more pictures of the rim elsewhere that would help confirm your analysis?

 

If it was helped along at some point it was dipped. But this one wasn't plated.

 

Interesting, I've seen lots of references to dipped but I've never figured out what it means. Does that mean dropping it into acetone or isopropanol? Or is there some other solution that people use?

Edit: Nevermind, found a youtube video.