I am going to say 66. I think the line on the eye brow and jaw line as well as spotting on the reverse will hold it back. That is a super nice cent and I would be proud to have it in the collection!
Sorry, a buddy if mine talked me into going to the sports bar for the Saints game last night. The photos highlight the spots on the reverse. They aren't very visible until you put a loupe on it. Here is the grade.