How would you Grade this 1934 Peace Dollar

I picked this up a couple of weeks ago and now it is finally sitting in its rightful plus on its webiste

http://www2.mrbrklyn.com/peace_coins.html

It seems to be a great specimen and to my eyes it grades about MS63.










How would you grade it?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ruben I think your're right on in your grade if there is no wear , which I can't tell with the pics , nice to see some of the later dated Peace dollars .
Rusty

 

thanks

Can yo tell the wear on this:

http://www.mrbrklyn.com/coins/02282009/peace_1934_P_o.1.png

 

sorry, i cant.. still too blurry. for my eyes anyway...

 

Better but still a little blurry , I don't know if '34s came weakly struck or if it's the pics , but I figure you've got her in hand and can tell so I'll go by your judgement that there isn't any wear , so I'll stick to MS-63 .
Rusty

 

And by the wat she's way prettier than Jefferson .:goofer:
rzage:hatch::hammer:

 

Based on the photos I would have to say Unc. details, cleaned.

 

What give the cleaning away , looks ok to me ?
rzage

 

I just picked up two PCGS MS 63 peace dollars today. If your pic's are accurate, yours looks better then mine. I say MS-64 based in your pics. Nice coin.

 

I am not the best at peace dollars but id say 63. lucky to get 64..

 

Does it still have cartwheel luster?

 

I think I would 4 it!

I think I would 4 it! - The 2 little hits on the face should not keep it from a 4 IMO.

 

yes - should i take a move of it?

Ruben

 

MS blurry-pics

 

Nice coin Ruben. I'll say MS 63.....................................John

 

MS-64, Ruben. I've gotten MS-62/63 Peace dollars that look way worse than that, (from NGC and PCGS). Peace dollars are extremely difficult to grade. Yours looks really good to me, the few hits nothwithstanding it passes other criteria.

I think it's the pics that make the coin appear cleaned to others. I looked really good at the coin and it doesn't appear cleaned to me. Do you have a macro feature on your camera? If so, use it and see what happens. That may clear up some of the blurriness.

 

I don't know. The camera just might be shot. I try a lot of different lighting and that one was in indirect sun light. God knows its taken enough pictures, 6493 of them to be exact. And then I drag it around in my Bike Messenger bag and once it died of power in Central Park with the Lens out and my daughter pushed the lens back in with her thumb. Its had a spot on the lens since then.

I'm sick of that camera. I want to get a real one, not a point once and shoot job.

Meanwhile, everyone is consistent though. I realized I posted this once before. Evidently I photographed it twice.

http://www.cointalk.com/forum/t46250/