6 months later and triple your money

I guess CAC didn't like it when it became a 68 lol....I assume the weak breast feathers are the reason

I applaud the consigner, I wish it would've been me

1898-O Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS-67 CAC (Toned) (Item 676391) | GreatCollections Coin Auctions







1898-O Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-68 (Toned) (Item 686206) | GreatCollections Coin Auctions

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

WoW ! Nice Coins .

 

Singular! Nice coin!

 

I think what Mike meant was, sometimes it doesn't pay to resubmit for grading. I could be wrong.

 

No, I think that he meant just the inverse. Sold 3/03/19 for $2500, and on 9/15/19 for $9000!

 

^this is what I meant

the toning all over the face makes it hard to see the luster, but I assume in hand the coin glows

 

Yes that's what I got out of it, that the 68 grade sold for a ton more
on the exact same coin.

 

If I changed doesn't to does, would that get me off the hook?

 

Sure, but only because you're a good guy!

 

I think he meant that CAC missed the boat on this one. At 67, why didn't they give it a gold sticker.

 

Cause it’s a strong 67 an a coin but a maxed out c coin at 68.

 

I’d buy it at pcgs 67 cac. Not at ngc 68 no cac

 

Same coin. Same exact coin. The only thing that changed was the holder and the presence/absence of a sticker. Yet the value was extremely strongly affected.

This exemplifies everything that is wrong with the US coin market. The coins themselves mean nothing. They cannot hold any significant value outside of a plastic holder. The plastic is where the value is placed, not the coin.

 

2500 to 9000 in just six months, wow! lucky devil...