Guess the grade 1857 seated dollar

Oh yeah ! ...and I usually do what the voices in my head tell me !

If I had 20 like this*, I'm sure I would talk myself into one more.








* which I don't

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

But I have the T-shirt to prove it ! :secret: :secret: :secret: :rolling:

Jim

 

Beautiful , MS-64PL .
rzage

 

Ms65

 

LOL thats a awsome shirt Jim.

 

I won't guess which grade since I looked to see how to grade these, but you are going to have to explain why when this is over. Even looking at their super large pics, I had trouble finding problems, but the others of the same grade were easy to find why.

 

NGC graded the coin ms-64. It is magnificent for the grade IMO. The eye appeal is greater than the picture may indicate.

 

No camera can capture great color. Must see to appreciate !

Do you feel this coin is PL ?

 

I would appreciate your explanation of that grade. That looks 65 maybe 66 to me.

 

To answer 900, I think the coin is mildly semi-pl, which I really think helps enchance the toning.

That being said I think the coin was graded a 64 due to some ticks on the reverse that are well hidden under the toning. I don't think most people would bat on eye if this coin was in a 65 holder, and I think many would argue that is the right grade for this particular coin.

 

Shucks Zane! I was going to say MS-65 but was too late in checking out the Thread. I know that I would not bat an eye if it was in a 65 holder! She sure is a beaut!


Frank