The Monster Toned Coin Game Thread

I love the sunset toning on this Buffalo. I'll agree with your 5.7!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I dissent, there are literally thousands of premium gem 1938-D Buffalo Nickels and many of them have more spectacular toning than this one. I’m at 3.5

 

I will split the difference. It is a 4.0 to me. Not a monster, but attractive toning.

 

It's a nice Buffalo but I'm not too bullish on it.
I might be the lowest but I'm only seeing a 3.0
(that was my first impression, I gave it some more thought, and came back with the same opinion).

 

I would be at 6 on MD11's Morgan.
3.8 on the buffalo.

 

I’m at a 3.0 on the Buffalo Nickel.

 

I'll play this game.

 

IMO the Norfolk is one of the nicest commemoratives. I give it a High Five, 5.6

 

3.2 on the Buffalo.

 

On mine I say 5.7 based on the grade of it, MS 68 CAC. I like the bi-metal look of the obverse but higher points aren't merited due to the terminal state of some toning.

 

The commemorative is nice, but it's too dark in a lot of places for my taste (particularly the obverse). I'm at a 4.8.

 

The Norfolk is impressive but the luster has to be muted a tad with toning that deep. I recall an MS68 Norfolk with bright golden toning that was unbelievable. I give this one a 5.0

 

The Buffalo is still in play and we can continue with the Norfolk as well (although let's try to not post new coins until the last round is called).

My score on the Norfolk will again be fairly low. It's a high grade but it doesn't pop out at me. I see the dark areas before the better toned ones....now remove the "outer ring", and I would go higher
I'm only at 3.9

 

5.0 on the Norfolk. It is pretty dark.

 

The Norfolk has a nice coloring scheme but I agree with those who mention it's darkness. With that in mind I'll go with a 4.

 

I am at 4.5 on the Norfolk.
When ever you want to call it @ddddd
Or am I supposed to?

 

I’ll let the pair of coins continue until tomorrow and then call it.

 

I have a couple more too.

 

Another Morgan waiting, also.

 

Norfolk = 4.9