OK, so there is a thread in the Coin Chat board (I think) about a nickel that change color...and I mentioned my Improperly Annealed Planchet nickel and someone asked how much it is worth...and I have no idea. I know we have discussed this coin before on this board (some felt it was overgraded) and there was a fun discussion. But, I have no idea how much the coin is worth. I don't collect error coins, but I bought it because it is dated 1985 which is my birth year...I thought it would be fun to put together an error set from 1985. Anyway, what do you think this coin is worth? Here's a pic: http://www.cointalk.org/album.php?albumid=76&pictureid=1609
There are a few, but they are different years. I don't know if that matters. Looking at the archives, they run from about $30 to $65 or so. But, most of those also have a lot more nickel showing...mine is nearly 100% copper in color.
I wouldn't be afraid to say that your coin could be worth $50-$100 to the right collector. The nearly complete copper wash makes it highly desirable. I don't think the year/date is an issue, although 1959 was one of the most common years for improperly annealed/sintered planchets.
If memory serves, there was at least one 1959 on heritage and it was one of the less expensive. The only place on mine where it is nickel in color is a small spot just below Jefferson's collar, slightly to the left of center of the coin. Other than that it is fully copper in color.
Exactly. 1959 is probably the most well-known date for this type/color nickel. The term "Black Beauty" comes from coin dealers who marketed them. I think that's what makes your coin desirable. Many copper washed coins aren't completely covered.
