I have a silver Roosevelt dime set (1946-1964) that I'd like to get a quick idea of its value. They are all slabbed MS-66 by either PCGS or NGC. I'm not interested in the laborious task of trying to find them one-by-one in auction results assuming that's even possible (eBay most likely). What printed or online listing would be the most reasonable. I have the monthly Coin World magazine and the bi-monthly PCGS RareCoin Market Report. Is there anything online that would be better than either of those two?
From what I can recall in my brief period of dealing with silver Roosie's, there weren't any real key dates to worry about. Assuming MS66, no FB, then we're talking around $25/coin, with a few exceptions here and there as some of the later dates sell for around $15, and some of the earlier ones around $50, notwithstanding if any of your coins have remarkable eye appeal, this would work out to $1200 for the set. PCGS's price guide has the full set of silvers at MS66 valued at $1099. Rather than going through the completed listings of each coin, as you stated, I think that the ballpark range of $1100-$1200 is suffice.
Chances are the PCGS graded ones have a high market value than the NGC pieces. PCGS has a huge hold on the modern coin market. Even if the NGC coin is better, it won’t matter. I thought that the 1949-P and S coins were better. Is that no longer true?
I almost always use the NGC price guide as my starting point: https://www.ngccoin.com/price-guide/united-states/dimes/32/ Assuming you have all 66 and no FT, a complete run of silver dimes is listed at $1330. As T$ mentioned, if you were looking to sell this set I'd probably start at around $1200.
