Odd counterstamped large cent

I love a puzzle and this one is puzzling. It’s an 1852 large cent, holed in the center and counterstamped 4 times - 2 per side perpendicular to each other. Even stranger is that none of the stamps seem to be identical.

I haven’t done too much searching but I couldn’t find it in Brunk. What do you think is going on?




I don’t want to influence what anyone else might see but each line seems different to me.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Somebody testing out counter stamps to see which one worked out the best?

 

One old superstition my grandfather mentioned was that a "penny" nailed on the door frame brought 'good luck' . Maybe the purpose of the hole and name.

 

Punches look the same to me, but it is longer than the coin is wide. So on some the first part is missing on others the last part is. Then the hole and the punches overtunning each other doesn't help.The punch appears to be E. H. BROWNELL

 

Counterstamped or not that hole makes it damaged.

 

Uh...so does the counterstamp

 

I think its kinda the way girls gave you there # back then. Had to make due without phones

 

I’d heard of nailing up a penny but not in conjunction with a counterstamp but I love this idea.

 

Sometimes the story or history is more interesting than any technical grade.

 

Yes but counterstamped coins are collectible. US coins with holes are not.

 

Wanna bet? I've seen a couple of people who post here who collect them.

 

@lordmarcovan comes to mind. The coin hat and vest he used to have.

 

A very quick search revealed one E. (Eugene) H. Brownell, b. Jan. 1, 1880. Worked for his father as "woodworker" (@ Brownell & Burt, Carriages, Sleighs; Tauntan, Mass.). Company eventually evolved into making auto bodies (Ford) as late as 1932. E. H. had 3 daughters, last b. 1917. Could he be the source????

Where, how, what were the circumstances of this acquisition?

 

Just bought it off eBay from user belmontcoinandjewelry out of Dayton, OH so anything is possible.