Legal counterfeit?

Discussion in 'Coin Chat' started by bruthajoe, Dec 19, 2019.

  1. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    How do companies get away with legally reproducing government currency and are they collectable? So called "Tributes". Screenshot_20191219-201652.jpg
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. -jeffB

    -jeffB Greshams LEO Supporter

    I don't see a denomination anywhere on the coin. I think that pretty much rules out "counterfeiting".
     
  4. YoloBagels

    YoloBagels Well-Known Member

    If they had an actual denomination that would be a different story. This is just a generic round made in a buffalo design.
     
    Larry E and bruthajoe like this.
  5. hotwheelsearl

    hotwheelsearl Well-Known Member

    Yea, this just counts as bullion. You see these all the time - approximations of actual designs, but with no denomination and a markedly less refined artistic quality
     
    Larry E likes this.
  6. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    This is not just a generic round though. It is an exact copy of real United States government currency. Just without the denomination.
     

    Attached Files:

    capthank and Paul M. like this.
  7. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    So if a government-issued coin no longer has a denomination is it real?
     
    Brina likes this.
  8. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    It just seems so borderline.
     
    Two Dogs likes this.
  9. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    I wonder if the company at least had to buy the rights for the design.
     
  10. Conder101

    Conder101 Numismatist

    Can't buy they right because other than the Sac dollar no US coin design is copyrighted.

    To a large extent it really depends on what the government says is counterfeit. Technically under the law a LOT of the generic rounds on the market could be considered counterfeits.

    Title 18 section 489 could conceivably be interpreted to make any round that has a device that looks anything like a device used on a US or foreign coin could be considered illegal. Not in the law it could be considered illegal if it was just the same COLOR or used the inscriptions. Just putting United states of america on it could make it illegal (if it isn't marked copy)

    Whoever, within the United States, makes or brings therein from any foreign country, or possesses with intent to sell, give away, or in any other manner uses the same, except under authority of the Secretary of the Treasury or other proper officer of the United States, any token, disk, or device in the likeness or similitude as to design, color, or the inscription thereon of any of the coins of the United States or of any foreign country issued as money, either under the authority of the United States or under the authority of any foreign government shall be fined under this title.
     
    Paul M. and Troodon like this.
  11. -jeffB

    -jeffB Greshams LEO Supporter

    I realize that that paragraph defines the law, but it's not very useful in this discussion. Just for starters, it would seem to criminalize plastic play money, not to mention reproductions properly marked COPY.

    It seems to me that if you interpret the statute to permit play money and HPA-compliant marked copies, there couldn't possibly be any problem with bullion coins that (a) leave off the denomination, (b) alter other design elements, (c) aren't even the same size, color or weight as the original coins, and (d) contain bullion far exceeding the face value of the original coins.
     
    bruthajoe and Troodon like this.
  12. Collecting Nut

    Collecting Nut Borderline Hoarder

    It's 1/10th gold bullion, not a coin, therefore it is not a legal counterfeit.
     
    YoloBagels likes this.
  13. baseball21

    baseball21 Well-Known Member

    Read that again. Something can't be an exact copy if you have to throw in the disclaimer that it's exact except for where it's different
     
    Troodon likes this.
  14. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    OK obviously not exact without denomination. so sorry.
     
    Kentucky likes this.
  15. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    Good point. But I wonder where they draw the line. What is it said "ONE DOLLOP"
     
  16. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    I hope I didn't start a new catchphrase. I hope we all know there's no such thing as a legal counterfeit. It's just contradictory and funny. Thanks for using it though I appreciate it.
     
  17. bruthajoe

    bruthajoe Still Recovering

    Thank you very much for this. I think this is the most definite conclusion.
     
  18. Conder101

    Conder101 Numismatist

    That is exactly the problem with the law I quoted. It is so vague they could make it apply to pretty much anything. You tick them off and it is a club they can beat you with. Eventually you may prevail, but it would cost you a fortune in legal fees to defend yourself.
     
    bruthajoe and Paul M. like this.
  19. Johndoe2000$

    Johndoe2000$ Well-Known Member

    Did anyone notice it says .24 gold, not 24K gold.
    This would make it a only 24% of 1/10 oz. of actual gold, or about 1/40th oz. of gold. Not 1/10th. Buyer Beware.
    Not the first attempt to fool people like this, and probably not the last.
    Better to buy bullion coins anyway. Safer, and easier to sell
     
    Two Dogs, Chuck_A and bruthajoe like this.
  20. Maxfli

    Maxfli Well-Known Member

    In which case, it's NOT an exact copy.

    To be clear, counterfeiting is a huge problem in numismatics. The gold bullion coin you cited isn't an example of that problem, however, because it's not intended to fool anyone.
     
    bruthajoe likes this.
  21. -jeffB

    -jeffB Greshams LEO Supporter

    Yes, I've seen that tactic before on eBay. I'm a lot more unhappy about that than about any resemblance to a circulating coin.

    This piece makes no attempt to deceptively resemble a US coin. It most certainly does attempt to deceive about its PM content.
     
    Stork, bruthajoe and Johndoe2000$ like this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page