grade for the $10 indian

this should spice up things for the rest of the week. the grade is only a 64

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Time for a green sticker.

 

Re submit. Id say its a 65 or 66, Sure is nice!if you crack it and resubmit it, is there anyway to get that dirt off without wrecking anything?

 

why not an upgrade to a 66?

 

doubling on the 13?

 

thats exactly what I was looking at, But it isnt there on the other photos, so I think its just reflection off the slab

 

Go for it if you think it could make it. My guess was 66 but I don't have the coin in hand. There may be some things not visible in the photos that would prevent it from reaching 66 but I see no reason why it would not grade 65.

 

which one isbetter this one or the princess? my money was on the princess but the whole forum is behind the indian?

 

That's a tough call. Which of your children do you love the most?

If I had to choose I would probably have to go with the Princess because I can't recall seeing one that nice before. Then again I can't recall seeing such a nice $10 Indian either.

The mintage of the Princess is about triple that of the Indian but I have no idea what the survival rates are for these coins.

According to my April 2007 PCGS Pop Report the 1862 $1 Princess in MS-65 has a population of 67 with 27 higher and the 1913 $10 Indian in MS-64 has a population of 216 with 58 higher (one as high as MS-67). So it would appear the Princess is a rarer coin in its grade than the Indian although a bump to MS-65 would put it (the Indian) in a population of 47 (46+1) with 12 higher (using the population of April '07).

 

nice pickup Spock......good eye !!

 

¿Want more proof of "buy the coin, not the slab"? I surely wouldn't mind that so referred to MS-64 over many of the 65's and even some 66's I have seen. That is a nice clean and free of chatter piece. If thee care not for it, for it's alleged grade is not lofty enough for thine to collect, perhaps one should consider that my numismatic harem would be a more suitable abode for her?

 

Well it is a beautiful 64. I agree it should be higher from what I can see from the pictures. Great coin spock1. Where is your CAC sticker? This one should certainly qualify.

 

Given the huge bump at 65 and 66, isn't it worth the submission? There is no way it could come in any lower! If you get it back 2 grades higher, you could turn it for a world-class rarity of some sort. Heck, you could even fill your gas tank with the profits! Mike

 

one more time please hopefully in a langauage i can understand

 

for it to fill my gas tank t would have to go to 67 but i am pretty sure we could see it in 65 maybe even in 66 but then since ia m not goin to sell it afterward pcgs will get even mor emoney out of me same story for the sticker but what a coin

 

If you do decide to sell - then I would re-submit it. It is one beautiful coin. Good eye spock.

 

GD is looking at the thread now a lil birdy tells me

 

Extremely beautiful, and an amazing buy.

 

Nice coin Spock!!

I was going to guess this was a pcgs coin. I nailed this coins grade. Strike i believe was the main reason. It wouldnt surprise me if you sent this one in three times, that it would come back three different grades.

Have a well known dealer send it in.More the better, if he was sending in a group of coins with the same quality. Would not surprise me if it were to come back a 66. This coin I believe is a PQ coin for sure!