GTG 1842-O Half Dime

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Close to 40, but i vote 35

 

Beautiful, original, semi-key date. That is a fantastic coin.

I voted VF-35, but it is a really nice one. I think it has just a tad too much wear for 40, and I would like to see at least hints of luster for a 40. Very nice coin!

 

Right on the cusp between 35 and 40, I'll guess 40.

 

40 drool

 

And.......it is rpd -001 1842/82

 

My gut said 40, so I voted that way. 35 seems fine too. Nice coin

 

40

 

My thoughts exactly

 

I don't collect these but I feel it just a bit too much wear for a 40 so I went 35. I'll split the difference at 37.5 but I've never seen that grade. lol

Definitely a nice key date as it's clean.

 

I went with 40. Nice surfaces. Started to call it a 45.

 

I was torn between 35 and 40. Personally I don’t think it’s got that much wear especially in the fields and is more strike. And it has a decent amount of trace luster. I went 40

 

I voted VF 35 ....I believe at least a trace of luster is needed for XF (but maybe that's just me reading Insider's posts from how grading used to work ).

 

VF 35 for me.

 

Started at 40, but I ended up at 35. Can I say 37.5?

 

I’m kind of like Paul. Stuck in the middle. I’ll go 40.

 

Voted VF35 as TC's coin is very similar in wear to my '40-O which was also graded 35 by you all.

 

VF 35