Hi welcome what a great coin I would say your coin is about a fine 12, an AU would be worth about $165,000 this is from the Redbook and photograde! Hope this helps!
Can't give you an AU Grade because the coin isn't AU. I am in The Fine to VF area also. And could possibly be netted on the low end because of the graffiti and harsh cleaning.
Definitely not better than F-VF, and it is damaged. Looks like traces of the mount in a slab on the rims.
That is a very scarce coin....unfortunately cleaned, scratched (and possibly holed and then plugged atop the bust??).
X2 I' definitely with @Eduard on this. Even though this is a scarce coin it will not grade other than cleaned and details. Despite that I would be glad to have this in my collection.
Fine scratched and cleaned and plugged . That being said I’d love to own it. A super rarity I’ve always wanted
I agree with others. Three things minimum keeping this rare coin from getting a low end VF grade. Technically probably a F, but most rarities like this get a grade upgrade.
Very rare coin. And AU55/58 is whackadoodle. That's a VF details, holed, plugged, cleaned, scratched, bent.
... among other answers you make it become a coin to melt for 10 dollars !!! It seems to me like hunting in the egg
I did not see anyone say this is worth melt. You got comments saying how scarce it is and that people would welcome it in their collection.