Which toned JFK do you prefer?

Okay, just curious. Which toned JFK do you prefer? #1, or #2? They are both the same grade—SP 66.




#1:



#2:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

2 jumps out way more to me.

 

I like them both. If I could only buy one it would be number 1 because the coin looks to be a better coin.
But the toning on number 2 is my favorite.

 

1

 

1

 

#1

 

It’s a draw.

 

#2. I prefer the color over #1, especially since #1 is no doubt much darker in hand when not flooded with light for a TrueView.

 

It is really close. I like both, but won’t buy both, as I have multiples of this date, toned.

 

#0

 

Very intelligent answer.

 

Thanks. Not a fan of damaged coins.

 

They aren’t damaged coins—obviously, your expertise does not extend very far in coin collecting. Weren’t you taught if you don’t have anything positive to say, don’t say it??

 

Yep. I ignored it though.

 

Which one do you need more ?
1966 ..
1967 ..

 

I like the subtleness of the toning curve on #1 compared to the "in his face" POP of #2

 

I agree. I think I came across overly critical of #1, but the truth is I would probably buy either one.

 

Yes they are.

 

Tossup. Multiples of both. It would be purely for toning quality, and they are so close.

 

Ok .
Then #2 ........