Redfield Dollar grade?

Well, I know Paramount put these general grades on these holders back in the day. Would this one be worth submitting for TPG . What grade would you expect?. Thanks

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Both obv & rev look pretty nice.

shot 5

 

Preserve the original provenance.

 

I believe they will grade and keep in original holders on the Redfields.

 

Define "they".

 

Thanks for your input

 

NGC

 

And thank you for answering the question.

Now seriously, thank you.

 

The pictures are a bit hard to grade from, but that looks like a solid 64 with a shot at 65. My understanding is that most of these are lower grade than that. And definitely keep it in the holder - that's where much of the interest for this coin lies.

 

It’s a nice coin. But I believe I once read that exposure to the old Paramount holders can damage the coin. Is that true or just a figment of my imagination?

 

I'm with Physics, 64, possible 65.

 

Here is another dollar I have in a Paramont holder, not indicated to be a Redfield. Which grade would you give this one and which dollar would you rather have taking into account date,mint, strike in relation to norm for date/mint and provenance.

 

Definitly the Redfield coin ...why?
The provenance....
The condition( there is a Scratch on the second coin)