GtGX2- ( 1883o & 1886p ) Morgans Toner Pair

I debated pretty hard on whether to go 64 or 65 on the 1886. First impression was 65, but I backed off for some reason. Maybe the other's comments. Both good lookers whatever the grade.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Are we looking at regrade numbers, if so 65 with * and the other stay's 63 with * unless the last one is darker then the photo.

 

I used natural light on 2nd coin reverse- 83o.
Its not at all darker in-hand. I didnt edit the photo, other than cropping, which im obviously no Andy Warhol

 

Wasn’t copying I can grade coins. I find their star designation very arbitrary though. I’d probably not give either the star myself

 

I dont think they are very scientific about the designation. Ive seen better that didnt get the star. Ive also seen coins w it, that NGC needs a mulligan on.

 

Couldn’t agree more. To me I’d give the star only to coins that are truly eye candy