1911 D wheat cent grade opinions...

Here is a 1911 D wheat cent that I am considering purchasing. Only $8, but there is sign of corrosion. What would you grade it without corrosion, and then what would you net grade it? Thanks ahead of time for all help and opinions. Also, any way that I can properly get rid of the corrosion so it doesn't do any more damage? Suggestions? Thanks ahead of time, and Merry Christmas to all!





Phoenix

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Cmon Doug, Problem coins need a home too.


I would say about 5-7 bucks on this one. Net it at F12.


It does have character. : )

 

as nice as it is, I wouldnt pay 8$ for it...

 

I was just asking if there was a way for me to help it, because I just don't want it to get any more damaged than it possibly is. I know I can't fix it, sorry about how I worded my question, I guess I came across wrong. How can I prevent it from corroding even more is what I meant to ask. Is there a safe way I can get rid of the corrosion so it doesn't do any more damage? Thanks for the help so far.

Phoenix

 

Photos not clear enough for proper appraisal but $8 is to much for what I can see.

 

that sure is one ugly coin

 

Safe- To get rid of the corrosion on the coin, without having to harshly clean it. I realise I am going to have to clean it if I buy it, but what would be the best to get rid of the corrosion without having to harshly clean it? I'm sorry, I really can't get the words I want from my head to the key board if that makes sense. What is the proper way to get rid of the corrosion? Acetone? Kaboom? Joking about the Kaboom. But please everyone understand, I know that I can not reverse the corrosion, and that I'll have to clean it in someway to get rid of it. My question is, what is the best way you recomend to get rid of the corrosion, without hurting the coin to bad with the cleaning? Thanks for the advice and help so far, and sorry for the confusion and me not coming across to clear.

Phoenix

 

I am sorry, I don't refuse to hear what you are saying, I just didn't understand you at first. Know I understand loud and clear. I am probably going to pass on it. But, I don't take this in vain or anything of the sort (for lack of better words), I learned a few things. I'll just save up now for my 09 S. Thanks a lot GD, and everyone else. :thumb: Merry Christmas and HAppy Holidays to all. :thumb:

Phoenix

 

I dunno... I've heard some tales. Corroded, holed coins rising from their graves to consume the brains of the living. Or were those zombies? Whatever.

But seriously, Phoenix, the question you should be asking is not "how do I remove the corrosion", it should be "how do I STOP the corrosion." The pinprick holes caused by the corrosion aren't going ANYWHERE. Unlike most forms of damage, such as holes or scratches, corrosion is a process. If the corrosion is still active, then when you buy it, it will continue to get worse! This is a problem I've faced numerous times on my ancient coins.

Of course, tt goes without saying that it is worth less than an uncorroded specimen (how much, I won't venture a guess). But a corroded coin still has SOME value.

 

Oh I agree with what GD is saying. A problem coin today is going to be a problem coin tomorrow. There is no bandaid to fix the issue. The problem has left its mark and there will always be a scar. Is it worth the effort on a minimally priced coin?

I was just saying that a problem coin needs a home too. : )

 

cleaning / attempting to fix coins only makes them worse. The only situation i can think of is PVC damage, the green gooey stuff that can be easily removed at no harm to coin with acetone. Other than that, it is what it is, and the advise given to you above is 100% correct.

 

for $8, you can buy a better one than that.

 

I like that answer. It goes along with 'always buy the best coin you can afford'.
GD's right ~ problem coins don't get better ~ they just get older. Yes, they all deserve a home but if you can afford a problem free coin for the same amount why not go 'that' direction. Fixing a problem coin is like fixing a wrecked car. You may make it look purty but deep down inside you'll always know it was a wreck that was just hidden. Then it falls in the hands of a novice collector who can't detect it and ... you get the point.

 

phoenix could actually get one in fine condition problem free if he looks hard enough. for me, as long as i can see the date it is fine. i'll probaly buy higher grade coins when i get older but the low grade ones are fine for now.

 

Yeah, I could, except I'm kind of more shooting for VF/XF though. This one has VF details IMO, but the damage just isn't worth it.

Phoenix