Guess the Grade

So , , , what's the "correct" answer?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'll post when I know.

 

63BN
61
63

 

I'm please with my guesses, except the Lincoln. WTG!

 

TVs

 

High end AU on the first two, a 63 or maybe a 64 on the 1916 Buffalo. That nickel sure is a nice example.

 

Looking at the TrueViews, I am surprised that the Barber did not get "details" due to the scratches on the cheek.

The Buffalo is still really nice. I think it will get a CAC bean.

 

I only looked at the coin once before I sent it to John for grading but I didn’t remember those scratches so I went and look at mine and they’re much lighter in my pictures but they’re there. If I would have looked closer I wouldn’t have sent it in.

The Buffalo I don’t know where the 63 is coming from but I’m happy it’s back in a straight graded holder.

 

MS61 on that 1911-D? MS61 is one butt-ugly coin, that coin isn't that ugly.

 

AU55, MS64, MS66

 

55
58
63

 

Yea imo the Buffalo should be higher grade. I dont see anything holding it back from a 65 unless the luster is just not there.
Are they tempting you to re-submit(?)
Hmmmmmmm

 

I think TypeCoin nailed it! Send um in and I think that Buff will go CAC also. I’m not a Buffalo nickel guy so I went 1 point low but think it’s probably better that I see!!

 

Thank you for the compliment, but according to PCGS I got every one of them wrong.

 

That’d be submission #3 and it’d have to grade a 65 for it to be worth it. I’ll see what cac says.