The Details Discount Thread

I have no idea on the grade but I'm guessing not details. $165

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

xf details, scratch, 310

 

$280
XF Details
Scratched (although I don't find the scratch to be that noticeable or bad thanks to the toning)

 

I'll say $150 XF- straight grade.
I think the TPGS are very lenient on old toned over scratches. It will be interesting to see which way they went with this one.

 

There would still be a shiny area where the two coins came in contact with each other - especially if it were an edge or rim. The "frost" would be removed.

 

This was a hard one to score!
We had beefer, pickin and grinin, jwitten, and johndoe with 3 marks...
@Johndoe2000$ wins on the price tiebreaker as I paid $81

The scratch is there (in the middle of the bust, extending from the neck), but it isn't too striking (meaning your eye does not go straight to it...actually I had to search for the scratch before I found it). This was cracked for my type set and I was happy to get it for the price as I watched worse examples go for $90-$100+

 

Points Table
Beefer518 - 10 Points
Johndoe2000$ - 7 Points
ron_c - 6 Points
KSorbo - 6 Points
ddddd - 6 Points
baseball21 - 3 Points
Pickin and Grinin - 3 Points
IBetASilverDollar - 1 Point
charlietig - 1 Point
jwitten - 1 Point
Charles REid - 1 Point

@Johndoe2000$ you're up...

 

Man, until you pointed it out I didnt see the scratch either. I was looking for what people were saying and couldnt find it! Great coin

 

I'll put one up tomorrow, unless someone wants to post one.

 

I'll post one if it's ok. I will have to read up on the rules before declaring a winner though! Here's a gold toner that I don't think I've posted on the toning premium page. Straight Grade? If not, why? Grade range? Price paid?

 

I'm gonna try to guess before anyone gets in so I'll not be influenced.

MS details, Scratched $320

 

AU details damage
$250

 

AU, Details scratched,$ 424

 

$325.... MS-details scratched

 

Had i not been using Ed Wood's assistants laptop, I would have noticed that scratch.

 

UNC Details - scratched - $280
...I still really like the look of this coin, but without what I think is a scratch (from the eye to the cheek area) this would be a much more pricey coin.

 

MS Details Scratched, $350. Nice looking coin, had to look for the scratch.

 

MS Details - Scratched
$375

 

For clarity... MS, and UNC are considered the same thing, so, even if the slab says UNC, MS is an acceptable term....right???

 

Yes - PCGS uses MS, and NGC uses UNC, but they are the same.