Should Long Nock be returned?

I would expect to double my money on that, conservatively. This is a (relatively) rare and more importantly, widely-known variety. People's ears perk up when you say, "1878-S Long Nock." Heck, I got $60 for this:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

So there ya go...I think the OP's coin has much better eye appeal that Dave's. If the OP doesn't like it, sell it and move on. I would not return it.

 

Keep it. Not worth the return.

 

Yeah...........proof read, proof read, proof read.