The Toning Premium Thread Part 2

Bought for $175
Sold for $350

PROFIT: $175

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'd like to change my guess - profit of $200

 

Already chosen

 

This is tough
Profit $50 (?)

 

I like the coin but.....
Were you thinking it was a 64 instead of a 65 @ron_c ???

 

$110 profit

 

Your are the winner.

The day I received it and regretted bidding on it after seeing it my friend and his friend, the acquaintance, came over as we were going to a coin show in Dallas the next day.

The acquaintance looked at the coin and said he would give me what amounted to be $50 over what I paid. When money and the coin exchanged hands, he started laughing at me as he just took me to the cleaners on the slabbed coin.

He collects error coins and slabs. It is listed as a 7166 - 1886 but the coin is a 7162 - 1885 O, which he claimed to be worth about $200 premium because of the error.

He tried to sell it the next day at the coin show but no one wanted it. Very shortly, he sold it on the same auction I bought it, but not any profit.

This is the same "acquaintance" I had posted before when he buys raw MS Morgans, common date, the first thing he does is to take silver polish and polish them up real good, bright and shiny. We have told him he ruined the value which he said he didn't care.

 

Yesssssssss
Ok Boys, another Morgan!! (Muaahaaahaa)
Recent pickup at the annual show here in Columbus....
I believe 1900p isnt really considered a common date for nicer toning.
PCGS MS63 - Book Price is $65
How much did i pay? (Photos suck btw)

 

I really don't know the toned coin premium market so I'm going to say $100.00

 

$117.19

 

$150

 

$98

 

$195.00

 

160

 

125

That is certainly not a date that shows up toned too often. And you have a nice range of colors. Nice coin!

 

$170

 

130

 

$95

 

$110

 

$120