115 This is a coin that I occasionally see in my searches and may one day pick up...as you said, this one shows the details of the design well. So among "problem" coins, it is a step above the rest.
$125, because of, as ddddd pointed out, the details are there, the coin is attractive enough, and it's something I think folks wouldn't mind owning as a type coin. I personally like it, and the details grading doesn't bother me much on a coin like this.
I only had the 1901 Morgan that was a Details Grade over on the Toned Thread. So someone else post something.
Here we have a 1841-C $2 1/2 Liberty, with slight damage I bought it raw for slightly above melt! I certified it genuine with anacs. How much did I sell it for? PCGS puts it at $2,000 in 35, $3,100 in 45.
Right now melt is around $155. Depending on when you sold it melt could have been much different. I am going to guess twice melt at the time the sale was made.