The Toning Premium Thread Part 2

$38

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

$45

 

$25 .. 1921 is a difficult date to find nicely toned. This example has some colors, but it very well might be AT or cleaned and retoned.

 

80

 

$125.00 I've been incredibly low on many of these lately, time to try a little higher.

 

$135

 

At over 10x + the PCGS guide price.... it makes me think that way. I'm beginning to see that there's some that like, REALLY like, and are not afraid to pay for, toners.

 

Well, I think everyone who is going to guess, has guessed, or have they? I'll give it another hour or so, then I'll reveal.

 

Yes I agree that the premium over guide is still significant. And there certainly are people that will pay strong prices for toned coins. Other times one can get toners for little premium. This thread has now displayed both cases.

 

Well, I paid $42.61 including shipping, so.......

@C-B-D would be the closest at $45

 

This is a bent, F-VF details 1809 normal edge bust half that I auctioned off starting at 99 cents. How much did it go for?

 

$45
...I wonder how much being bent would discount this as I would think that could be a deciding factor (for example, I'm avoiding bent coin for my type set because they might not fit properly in my album).

 

That's one reason I wanted to post this coin. It's a problem coin, but still purty.

 

Yes it does have some attractive features.
And based on my guess you can see I didn't cheat
Maybe I should have though

By the way, you might want to add an average price for one of these in problem-free Fine grade.

 

$150

It doesn't look crazy bent, and has nice toning with a nice wear pattern. I also think green toning like that is desirable.

 

Numismedia says F12 and VF20 are $174 and $252 respectively.

 

Points Table
IBetASilverDollar - 5 Points
ddddd - 5 Points
Beefer518 - 4 Points
C-B-D - 4 Points
brg5658 - 3 Points
heavycam.monstervam - 3 Points
baseball21 - 3 Points
jwitten - 2 Points
Johndoe2000$ - 2 Points
Volante - 1 Point
jtlee321 - 1 Point
moneycostingmemoney - 1 Point
KSorbo - 1 Point
Pickin and Grinin - 1 Point
ddoomm1 - 1 Point
ron_c - 1 Point

I tried some new formatting, but it didn't turn out too well....so back to the old table

 

$100 (Have no clue)

 

Hmmm. Bent raw and 99 cent starting but nice color so many variables lol. I'll guess about half of VF price, $120

 

175 shot in the dark