Lamination or PMD?

Discussion in 'Error Coins' started by Swan, Jul 5, 2017.

  1. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    What's everyone's opinion on this one?[​IMG]
     
    Tyler Graton likes this.
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. lordmarcovan

    lordmarcovan 48-year collector Moderator

    I had initially thought PMD (corrosion or acid etching - and that still might be the case), but seeing how intact LIBERTY remains above that void makes me wonder if this one did not indeed get struck on a seriously laminated, messed-up planchet. Could be.

    I'm no error/variety specialist, so I'll defer to those who are.
     
    Tyler Graton and Swan like this.
  4. eddiespin

    eddiespin Fast Eddie

    Those look like laminations. There are cuts on the coin, and a big one on the coat, just under the tie. Those cuts are the pmd.
     
    Swan likes this.
  5. Tyler Graton

    Tyler Graton Well-Known Member

    Plus I never seen a lamination with all that black and green stuff all over it. Liberty looks like it melted kinda (to me)! Looks like there was acid on it, and while the acid was eating away, looks like they may have moved the penny and to me it looks like the liquid movement downward in liberty. When I look at a true lamination ( not saying this isn't) I see longer, straighter, sharper lines, I still see some laminations with fully intact devices, but usually the edge of the affected hole shouldn't have rounded edges. (Kind of think of it like this, when you rip apart a coke can, it's not gonna have round edges, they will be sharp. This is just my observation, justninformarion that may help you determine yourself
     
    Swan likes this.
  6. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    I thought it looked like lamination, but I wasn't sure on this one. I debated soaking it in acetone to clean it up some, but the grime really highlights the lamination.
     
    Tyler Graton likes this.
  7. Tyler Graton

    Tyler Graton Well-Known Member

    It looks like it to me too and would be something I would have a question on too. I'm only looking at other laminations and don't see any similarities. I would try that though. Maybe there's something under all that crud
     
  8. lordmarcovan

    lordmarcovan 48-year collector Moderator

    It could be some kind of acid damage or corrosion that happened prior to the strike, which would count as a minor error ("planchet flaw") rather than PMD.

    But I dunno for sure.
     
    Tyler Graton and Swan like this.
  9. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    I see what you mean about straighter sharper lines. They do look kind of fluid looking.
     
    Tyler Graton likes this.
  10. Tyler Graton

    Tyler Graton Well-Known Member

    I love it when I can think like a detective. Haha I would wait for a few more responses just to be sure cause I still learning myself IMG_1541.JPG
     
    Swan likes this.
  11. Tyler Graton

    Tyler Graton Well-Known Member

    Could you get a closer picture of liberty please?
     
  12. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    This is the best I can get with my camera. Not sure if it's any better.
    If it was acid the word LIBERTY seems to be unaffected.
    [​IMG]
     
  13. cpm9ball

    cpm9ball CANNOT RE-MEMBER

    I would like to see the reverse of the coin.

    Chris
     
  14. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    [​IMG]
     
  15. Tyler Graton

    Tyler Graton Well-Known Member

    IMG_1542.PNG IMG_1543.PNG
    Looks to me like the acid also took its shape on the other side. They are in the same spot, and shapes resemble the obverse and the reverse of you outline both affected areas with your eyes. Straaaange things are happening on this coin. Lol.
     
    Swan likes this.
  16. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    There was a lot of acid in the 80's
     
    Tyler Graton likes this.
  17. Tyler Graton

    Tyler Graton Well-Known Member

    Hahaha I bet. Dmt is where it's at though haha
     
    Swan likes this.
  18. paddyman98

    paddyman98 I'm a professional expert in specializing! Supporter

    That is the nastiest looking Cent I have ever seen... yuck! :vomit:
     
    Tyler Graton and Swan like this.
  19. Swan

    Swan A millon dollars short of being a millionaire

    Haha. This ones a keeper.
     
  20. cpm9ball

    cpm9ball CANNOT RE-MEMBER

    After seeing the reverse, I'm thinking that it is chemical and/or environmental damage.

    FWIW, a dozen years ago or so, I watched a TV special about a collection service that contracted to gather the coins from the fountains in various malls and other buildings. The business had to clean the coins before they could be exchanged for cash. You might be surprised to learn about the methods they used and the chemicals that were employed to clean the coins. Suffice it to say that they definitely were not coin collectors.

    Chris
     
    Swan and Tyler Graton like this.
  21. Paddy54

    Paddy54 Well-Known Member

    I remember that piece on the company that gathered and cleaned coins from wishing wells etc....yeah even putting 1000 ' s in a rock tumbler to get the crud off..... yeah seriously cleaned coins. And what he got a cut of the total amount to pay him for his services ?
     
    Swan likes this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page