Post your Under-Graded Slabs (Official Thread)

It's a specimen that for my shield nickel collector I love to have....but personally I think the grade is rock solid.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

You guys can't see it in-hand, which is essential for proofs. It's like holding a hunk of glass.

 

You know I love holding a hunk of glass!
Especially when filled with my favorite beverage Cerveza Mas Fina

 

I love proof shields btw, Larry Briggs had a prooflike shield nickel in a segs slab once upon a time at the cona show. Wish i wouldve snapped a photo or 2 so i could study it to see if wasnt really just a proof

 

I was wondering? What are the Marks on each side of the shield. The right side, they look don't look like they are on the slab?
MY fav. is Coors Light.

 

Mexican Beer used to be good. Sampled some recently and it was abhorrently, abysmally lacking in body and texture. Such a disappointment.....

 

Now that's the way to do it!!!!!

 

I started drooling uncontrollably when I saw these. I love that they are a matching set. I want one sooooo bad..

 

I want to see someone put together a full gold sticker type set

 

In old no line fatty NGC slabs...

 

Just got this one back from CAC.

 

Couple things-
1) THAT coin is the epitome of what this thread is about !
2) Why on earth did they grade that at 64?
Its not even a super old holder.
3)Im noticing this generation of NGC has quite a few under graded Morgans, @jtlee321 has stumbled acrossed a few himself.
Lastly, that coin, to me, has a very clean cheek even for a MS66

 

Very nice, i think mercs are 1 of the easiest series to find undergraded like that.
What are we thinking on this one??
67???

 

That looks like a pretty easy 67 to me.

 

Here's the one I posted at the start of this thread, after it came back from CAC.

 

...picked this up for $108. Probably graded correctly but looks like NGC (with the special label and it's the 69th coin graded in that sub) may have missed the suffix



...here is another from same seller for scan comparison.



...we will see

 

Sweet coin nice pick up Justin

 

Im glad you brought this thread back to life-
Heres one

 

I actually agree with the grade on that one. The obverse field is pretty chewed up.