Now THAT's a nice one, with some potential! Not only a nice example, but a better date, too! Edit: that is THE key date for the type, and in a popular series, to boot! I say AU minimum, and agree with @Numismat that it has $100+ potential if it straight-grades. Potential. This one should cross into 3-figure territory (if just barely) in terms of catalog value. In terms of real-world market value, would it sell for more than a hundred bucks? That might be a stretch, and would take some luck. But it's a helluva nice cherrypick, regardless.
At less than 50 cents, you scored a home run on this one. I can help with getting it graded if you are very patient. I hope to be submitting some stuff to NGC in the next month or so (and then there's another month's turnaround...)
Side note: also would have offered to send it to NGC as well, but I JUST sent in my pre-summer break world coin submission. Will have some fun GTG when they return. Best of luck, whatever you decide!
Offer is most appreciated. I may take you up on your offer. The local dealer was sending his express which I assumed drove up grading costs. I will post on EBay BIN/BO initially most likely with some other coins. If I read correctly, I will owe fees only what on what sells. I would rather a fellow collector reap a good price than EBay collecting fees.
Really, though, what I would do if this were my coin, is get a slightly better picture of it, hang it out there on eBay at a 99c starting bid, and let 'er rip. It'll find its own value that way. For a 50c-plus-eBay-fees investment, I don't see how you could lose. But alternately, you could go the BIN/BO route, instead. Really, this is not one of those coins that HAS to be certified. Would that help sell it, since it's a key date? Maybe. Maybe not. I dunno. I cherrypicked a better-date 1870s Danish coin with a catalog value in the low- to mid-$100s about four years ago (it had cost me about 10-20 cents in a bulk bag, very much like your now-famous "tub"). I hung it out on eBay raw. Can't recall what it sold for- not full catalog by any means- but I was happy. I think it did just barely reach $100-ish. I don't think it would've fetched that much more in a slab, because I slabbed the next-best one out of that lot (there was another nice Danish piece in there), and that one did OK in the slab, but really not as well as the one I sold raw. So don't feel like you have to slab it. Sell it as-is, and you're basically in that pure-profit sweet spot no matter what. And then you haven't laid out $35-40+ for slabbing. That "almost-pure-profit" thing is the beauty of cherrypicking bulk lots of world coins here in the USA, where lots of people ignore the "foreign junk". I've been at the game a long time. Sometimes the cherrypicking and swapping and selling can really reap dividends. It's fun AND educational. And with some work, profitable.
I was going through my coins today and came across my version of this coin. Ignore the dust in the picture - I need to clean my scanner. I bought this on eBay. I don't know what I paid but I doubt it was more than $30 or so.
These are the best pics for EBay. I appreciate your input. I have been flooded with opinions on price and grade.
I predict you'll come out smelling like a rose on this one. Nice pix. Shoot me a link when it's on eBay and I'll start the bidding if you go the low start/true auction route.