1928P Peace dollar

What grade would you say this one is?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Low MS or High AU. I suspect it's been cleaned. There's a good amount of original luster, but I don't like the lines in the field in front of her face and the cheek & neck.

If I had to give a number I'd say AU-58 Details.

 

fair enough. I didn't think it looked cleaned but maybe.

 

I'll go with AU something Details cleaned.

 

so if the consensus is lightly cleaned what net grade should it command? Fair retail price?

 

Similar coins on eBay go for around $300. Of course the fees would be about $40 + shipping (at the very least $6). So personally if I was buying this to resell on eBay, I'd be at about $190-$220.

-Edit-
Oh by the way, have you inspected the mintmark area to see if it might have been altered?

 

My wild guess would be $300 at auction.

 

Don't have the coin in hand.

 

May have been cleaned but if not, AU-55.

 

Cleaned so details grade at AU-55

 

I’m wondering if it’s been whizzed. The surfaces seem very pebbly.

 

With the reverse being dinged up I'd call it a XF45

 

XF ish......

 

Not every coin with details is shot and worthless, that IS a KEY date. I'll take it if you don't want it. We really should start a thread regarding our favorite details coin. And I'm not saying that is cleaned or altered, just saying.

 

I'm just seeing lots of tiny marks all over the coin. I agree it's not a typical shiny whizzed look.