Is this Roosevelt not a MSFT-65 or better? I'm kinda new, am I missing anything? Working up a submission and I'd like to include it, but not to come back worth 9 bucks. Thanks!
It would be a waste of money to grade that dime. I’ve purchased better looking coins graded and slabbed by PCGS for $5.00.
I appreciate the input. What's wrong with it? It's uncirculated, it's not scratched or damaged, it's has full luster, and full bands. It looks every bit as good or better than the Photograde examples at PCGS in the mid to upper 60s to me. What am I missing? Thanks.
Nothing wrong with it, really. It’s just not worth enough to justify the considerable expense of certifying it, is all. There’s no upside there. Even in your best-case scenario, it will grade out at a level that will make the coin only worth a small fraction of the cost of submitting it. It’s a nice enough coin for a raw album. Not for a slab. Unless you don’t care about the expense and just have a burning desire to slab it- in which case, go right ahead. But that would be a waste of money. As @Collecting Nut mentioned, you could find a nicer example already in a slab for less than ten bucks, most likely. So why spend $40-50++ to slab that one? Even if you used the economy tier for moderns, by the time you add up the grading fee, the invoice fee, and shipping both ways, you’d be way underwater on it.
You said it yourself. That, I think, is a very plausible scenario. Nice though the coin may look, I do not like your odds of doing any better than that.