I just took a second look at mine and it does appear that where it looks rough and irregular on yours is almost identical to mine. Maybe it is the way it was struck.
I've got one of those in copper. Bought it because it was a Daniel Carr piece and because the mintage was 60, but when I got it, it was nicer than I would've ever thought. Hey @physics-fan3.14, I heard you absolutely love the Daniel Carr pieces!
How is it you got a copper version of this? I thought they were only made available to members of the club. Are you a club member?
I realize you are trying to provoke me. However, I have always said that Dcarr's original pieces, club medals, etc, are well designed and executed incredibly well. I admire his artistry when he sticks to original pieces.
LOL.... somebody had to be the brave one. But, I do agree with your point about the original pieces. I have no idea as to how he makes them so well (probably computers) but I do wonder if there are other clubs he has made medals for. I'll have to research that.
This web site lists medals he has made for other clubs http://www.moonlightmint.com/dc-coin_medals_club_A.htm
The Madison County Coin Club had a total of 40 silver, 60 copper, and 20 brass medals minted. The brass medals were sold to club members only.