The fields do seem near-reflective. I can see justification for a Star. There's just the slightest bit of tickery in the hair and on the shield, enough to probably keep it from 68 when the grader knows 68 is a $10k coin.
Well, it also has to not only keep the CAM designation but probably upgrade to DCAM; 68's are cheap without it. It's like $150 in 68, $500 in 68CAM, and north of $8k in DCAM.
They were a weakness for this one, for me too, and I just tried to recover as gracefully as possible. At least, paying undivided attention to something is a weakness for me.